DebateNation
Politics • Spirituality/Belief • News
Politics. Religion. Whatever.
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?

Learn more first
February 23, 2022
Whatever Happened to Nuance?

So tired of watching news these days. I mean, I'm so tired of watching what's considered to be news programming. Clearly we're no longer in the days when you would turn on the news, get the facts, then watch your favorite late night talk show.

We're bombarded by opinion and what scares me the most is that I don't think our education system works well enough for most people to be able to determine what is fact and what is opinion. And almost all of the time, the opinion you seem to hold is really close to the opinion your parents hold or what part of the country you live in, or where you went to school or college. Nobody thinks for themselves these days.

I've been accused of being contrarian for my views. Apparently I'm just going against the grain just to go against the grain. I've been accused of that a couple of times, actually. Apparently I voted for a woman candidate not because she most closely aligned with what I expect from a President, but just so I could get Trump elected without having to actually vote for him. As if not voting for either of the mainstream candidates that have been credibly accused of sexual assault isn't reason enough.

I can watch Fox News and pick out the parts that are actual news and filter out the parts that are the commentary meant to cater to the die hard red voter. The ones the comedy shows always get to do interviews. I can also watch CNN and do the same thing. I can get past snide remarks or condescending comments and just pay attention to the actual facts.

As an example - immigration. If you were to watch CNN, you'll hear all day long how conservatives hate immigrants because they want a wall built. But that's just being dishonest. They know conservatives are against illegal immigration. That illegal part is what they can't bring themselves to say, but that's the nuance that's missing. In this case, it's a very big nuance that they're purposely leaving out because that's how you frame a narrative you're trying to push.

Now, so I'm not accused of being contrarian, let's talk about how Fox News frames their narrative around the same subject. Most problems with immigration stem not from the southern border, but by people coming here on a legitimate visa and then overstaying. If you were to only listen to Fox News, you would believe the opposite. Again, they're framing the 'facts' to fit the narrative.

There is nuance to this debate. We have a problem with southern border immigrants and immigrants overstaying their visas. Both can exist at the same time. Why can't Fox News mention the visa overstays and why can't CNN say that conservatives are against people coming here illegally? Because it's not about making sure you get the facts, it's about catering to whoever pays the bills. But that's for another discussion.

It's all about the nuanced middle and neither extreme.

If you can't honestly imagine why someone would vote for the flawed Donald Trump* or any republican, you have no ability to think past your biases. If you can't honestly imagine why someone would vote for the flawed Joe Biden* or any democrat, same. Understanding someone else's position doesn't mean you agree with it, it just means you can see where they're coming from, and you will end up having a better discussion with them. (For the record, everyone is flawed.)

These are just the words I vomited out after listening to both CNN and Fox News on the framing around the Russian/Ukraine tension going on right now. Fox News wants you to think we should stay away from that whole thing and focus on our own problems. CNN thinks we should totally go in and help another democracy. Why can't they both be a little right? Instead Fox News is saying CNN wants to go to war because Ukraine has dirt on Joe Biden. CNN is saying Fox News wants to stay out of it because republicans love Putin. Why can't they both be wrong?

There's nuance in everything. If you're watching/reading just one source, pinch your nose and watch/read a source that disagrees with you and see if you can pick out the facts amidst all the opinion. It will make you a better person.

Or like me, it'll make you more bitter for the world that I'm leaving behind.

*Other than being a dumbass. <-- this is what a critical thinker would say as a joke and a non-critical thinker would give as the only reason.

Interested? Want to learn more about the community?

Learn more first
What else you may like…
Posts
April 21, 2023
Jumping to Conclusions: The Dangers of Assuming Racism Before All the Facts are Known

In today's digital age, social media has provided a platform for people to voice their opinions and reactions to news stories and events almost instantly. Unfortunately, this has also created a culture where people jump to conclusions and make assumptions without having all the facts. This is particularly true when it comes to issues of race, where allegations of racism can quickly spread on social media and cause public outrage before all the details have been established.

The recent incident involving an 85-year-old man shooting a young black man who was allegedly trying to break into his home is a perfect example of this phenomenon. Before any information had been released about the incident, people on Twitter were actively doxing the alleged perpetrator, assuming that he was a racist who had shot the young man because of his race. However, as more details have emerged, it has become clear that the situation is much more complex than initially assumed.

It is possible that the ...

March 30, 2023
Gun Control?

The issue of gun control in the United States is a complex and controversial topic, with advocates on both sides of the issue. While some believe that individuals have the right to bear arms under the Second Amendment, others argue that the easy availability of guns contributes to the country's high rate of gun violence. Regardless of where one stands on the issue, it is clear that there is a need to get guns off the streets or at least out of the hands of people who should not have them.

The United States has one of the highest rates of gun violence in the world. According to the Gun Violence Archive, there were over 43,000 incidents of gun violence in the United States in 2021, resulting in over 23,000 deaths and over 42,000 injuries. This level of gun violence is unacceptable and something needs to be done to address it.

One approach to addressing gun violence is to enact stronger gun control laws. This could include universal background checks, waiting periods, and restrictions on the sale...

March 12, 2023
Trump's Narcissism Hinders Allyship and Progress for Republicans

Donald Trump's narcissism is well-known and widely documented. He has a deep need for attention and validation, and he often puts his own interests above those of others. This has become particularly evident in his relationship with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, who could be a valuable ally for Trump.

DeSantis has been a strong supporter of Trump and his policies, and he is seen by many as a rising star in the Republican Party. He has also been praised for his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic in Florida, which has earned him a great deal of respect and admiration.

However, despite DeSantis's potential as an ally, Trump seems unable to let anyone else share the spotlight. He frequently criticizes DeSantis and other Republican leaders, even when they are working to advance his own agenda.

This kind of behavior is characteristic of narcissistic personality disorder, which is a mental condition that affects a person's ability to relate to others. Narcissists often have a grandiose sense of ...

Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals